Skip to content

Commit 8e1264a

Browse files
matjazonlineclaude
andcommitted
Record the memory service's final integration review and acceptance
Phase 06 is accepted on the integrated tree (review MEM-P06-C-R2, digest 58acbacb...8e39), which completes the memory-service plan. The records carry the 06C evidence for the merged tree, including the pre-existing transport-boundary failure that stops CI's verify job on main. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 801839f commit 8e1264a

31 files changed

Lines changed: 13198 additions & 2 deletions

‎plan/memory-service/COORDINATION.md‎

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
22

33
- Authority: /Users/mac03/.codex/worktrees/60a0/openbot/plan/memory-service/COORDINATION.md (worktree 60a0, detached HEAD on a6bed48a; untracked)
44
- Writer: root session 6fedfb2e-40aa-486c-bd0b-051b5a3add7b (main conversation), worktree /Users/mac03/.codex/worktrees/60a0/openbot
5-
- Revision: 4 (2026-11-10: I003 gains U7)
5+
- Revision: 7 (2026-11-10: p06 accepted, plan complete; pushed under I001 r2)
66

77
Phases run sequentially in this one worktree. Phases 01–04 (the standalone service) and the phase-05
88
architecture gate plus batch P7b were completed under `implement-opus-reviewed`; their records stay at
@@ -63,7 +63,7 @@ Phase 05 continues under `implement-opus-reviewed-2_2` from 2026-11-08 ~20:10Z.
6363
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
6464
| p01–p04 | root 6fedfb2e (implement-opus-reviewed) | 60a0 | tmp/memory-service-run/progress.md (accepted locally) |
6565
| p05 | root 6fedfb2e (implement-opus-reviewed-2_2 from ~20:10Z); **accepted in phase 2026-11-10** (final digest 88808f5a…b0a1) | 60a0 | plan/memory-service/phases/p05/docs/TASK.md, HANDOFF.md |
66-
| p06 | root 6fedfb2e (implement-opus-reviewed-2_2), started 2026-11-10 | 60a0 | plan/memory-service/phases/p06/docs/TASK.md, HANDOFF.md |
66+
| p06 | root 6fedfb2e (implement-opus-reviewed-2_2), started 2026-11-10; **accepted in phase 2026-11-10** (final integrated digest 58acbacb…8e39, merge HEAD 801839fd); the commit carrying this record is pushed to origin/main per I001 r2 | 60a0 (merge in tmp/memory-service-run/merge) | plan/memory-service/phases/p06/docs/TASK.md, HANDOFF.md |
6767

6868
## Cross-phase notices
6969
None.

‎plan/memory-service/phases/p06/docs/HANDOFF.md‎

Lines changed: 19 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -44,3 +44,22 @@
4444
- 2026-11-10 (later): **p06-B3 (06B, B2-F1, U8/U9) accepted in phase**: B PASS MEM-P06-B3-R2 at
4545
digest 3617afd0…9405 (tree 607df2cd), recomputed by root. Next: integration with origin/main
4646
(TASK.md "Push authorization"), then 06C on the merged tree.
47+
- 2026-11-10 (later): integration done. Branch `memory-service` commit `41be07b2` (this plan's
48+
paths only); merge of `origin/main` cd73cc45 in worktree `tmp/memory-service-run/merge`,
49+
branch `memory-service-merge`: `084053ee` merge, `29d51abc` merge fixes (exactness kinds,
50+
`pub(super)` module), `5c8528a0` binary location from `cargo metadata`. 06C ran on the merged
51+
tree and passed, except failures already on clean main, a flake already on main, and the
52+
checks unavailable here (TASK.md "Integration and 06C"). Re-fetched: main unchanged, so the push
53+
is a fast-forward. Frozen digest 03e238f9…b88b2c (HEAD 5c8528a0, clean; records excluded).
54+
Final integration review MEM-P06-C-R1 sent to B. Next: on a pass, copy this plan's final
55+
records into the merge worktree and commit them, then re-fetch and push
56+
`memory-service-merge:main`. Then clean up: merge worktree (node_modules symlink, model copy),
57+
the c06 databases and the private cluster, and stop B. The paid smoke stays open for the user.
58+
- 2026-11-10 (later): **phase 06 accepted; plan complete.** B PASS MEM-P06-C-R2 at digest
59+
58acbacb…8e39 (HEAD 801839fd), recomputed by root. C-F1 was fixed in the records, C-F2 (a)
60+
was taken and C-F2 (b) declined with an accepted reason. The final records are committed
61+
into the merge worktree, then `memory-service-merge` is pushed to origin/main as a
62+
fast-forward.
63+
- Open: the paid smoke (user key); the transport-check CI blocker, pre-existing on main.
64+
- Cleanup after the push: the merge worktree (with its node_modules symlink and model copy),
65+
the c06 databases, the private cluster, and stopping B.

‎plan/memory-service/phases/p06/docs/REVIEW.md‎

Lines changed: 16 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -20,6 +20,22 @@
2020
| MEM-P06-B2-R1 | batch review | p06-B2 (A4: auth breaker, after-restore, backup check, operations docs, overload/load, OpenBot A4-8/A4-9 and restore SQL) | claude-opus-5-5 / xhigh (B abdd866fb428eea05) | a83ffe8402206d2cbee9aa6856c4666fc130a5f500bb3dffa42e08bef8e9afd1 (freeze tree fb435320) | **PASS** for p06-B2; optional F1 (breaker test timing, static gauge). Service 174/0/2, backup check 1/0, OpenBot `memory` 167/0/3; no reviewer mutation probes (disk at the floor) | [notes](agent-review-notes.md) MEM-P06-B2-R1; [findings](agent-review-findings.md) |
2121
| MEM-P06-B3-R1 | batch review | p06-B3 (06B.1 standalone journey, 06B.2 `memory_e2e_`, 06B.3 topology and isolation, 06B.4 competing claimants, B2-F1, U8/U9 paid smoke) | claude-opus-5-5 / xhigh (B abdd866fb428eea05) | b86dc1e8992a694729b968f3b9b5511100f6cd4e8ea39f154ed55e33d0f64b0e (freeze tree 540efd56) | CHANGES REQUIRED: 2 Minor actionable (F1 isolation check fails on a fresh, unmigrated OpenBot database, as in CI; F2 provenance and production-image coverage), 1 optional (F3 a–e); B2-F1 resolved. Journey 13/13; live script 6/0 only after a manual migration; focused service tests 3× ok | [notes](agent-review-notes.md) MEM-P06-B3-R1; [findings](agent-review-findings.md) |
2222
| MEM-P06-B3-R2 | correction recheck (F1, F2, F3a–e) | p06-B3 | claude-opus-5-5 / xhigh (B abdd866fb428eea05) | 3617afd03fefe97f517200b0a4a266940ab3441f0e27c9f5b8b4d20f2c249405 (freeze tree 607df2cd) | **PASS** for the whole batch p06-B3 (R1–R2): F1 fixed (no-grant probe table; reviewer live script on a never-migrated database 6/0), F2 fixed (raw-fetch provenance; image journey recorded unavailable, carried to 06C), F3 a–e taken. Journey 13/13; race test 3×; clippy/fmt clean | [notes](agent-review-notes.md) MEM-P06-B3-R2; [findings](agent-review-findings.md) |
23+
| MEM-P06-C-R1 | final integration review | p06-C (merged tree for origin/main: 41be07b2 + merge 084053ee + fixes 29d51abc, 5c8528a0, doc a534a6a7) | claude-opus-5-5 / xhigh (B abdd866fb428eea05) | 19b979d52842d2f65549197f24ed6ea155cad2f8ef1ba2057f96100d85a24f0c (HEAD a534a6a7; first request 03e238f9…b88b2c at 5c8528a0) | CHANGES REQUIRED, records only: F1 Minor (06C record omits the failing transport check, pre-existing on main, and `git diff --check`; one merge log is main's binary; 10 vs 12; no post-fix log); F2 optional. No code or merge-resolution finding. Reviewer: merge `memory_`/exactness/data_url 170/0/7, live script 6/6 with shared target, boundaries | [notes](agent-review-notes.md) MEM-P06-C-R1; [findings](agent-review-findings.md) |
24+
| MEM-P06-C-R2 | final integration recheck (C-F1, C-F2) | p06-C (merged tree, HEAD 801839fd) | claude-opus-5-5 / xhigh (B abdd866fb428eea05) | 58acbacb9e1cebcb2f3ec470ef643959cf97dcbc09fc7e48b192edf056aa8e39 (HEAD 801839fd) | **PASS** — final pass on the integrated tree (I001 r2): C-F1 fixed in the records, C-F2 (a) taken, (b) not taken (reason accepted). Records-only delta; the pre-existing CI transport-check blocker must be in the push report | [notes](agent-review-notes.md) MEM-P06-C-R2; [findings](agent-review-findings.md) |
25+
26+
## MEM-P06-C-R2
27+
28+
- **PASS** for the integrated tree (digest 58acbacb…8e39, HEAD 801839fd). This is the final pass I001 r2 requires before the push.
29+
- [MEM-P06-C-F1](agent-review-findings.md#mem-p06-c-f1--the-06c-record-omits-two-non-passing-gates-and-cites-one-log-that-is-mains-binary): fixed in the records.
30+
- [MEM-P06-C-F2](agent-review-findings.md#mem-p06-c-f2--optional-one-sentence-in-the-decisions-note-one-untested-piece-of-wiring): (a) taken; (b) not taken, reason accepted.
31+
- Carry to the push report: CI's `verify` job stops at the pre-existing transport-check failure, both on main and after the push. The paid smoke is still open.
32+
33+
## MEM-P06-C-R1
34+
35+
- **CHANGES REQUIRED** (records only) for the merged tree (digest 19b979d5…4f0c, HEAD a534a6a7).
36+
- [MEM-P06-C-F1](agent-review-findings.md#mem-p06-c-f1--the-06c-record-omits-two-non-passing-gates-and-cites-one-log-that-is-mains-binary): record the failing transport check (a CI `verify` step, pre-existing on origin/main) and `git diff --check`, relabel the merge mcp-flake log (main's 3859-test binary), fix 10→12, cite the post-fix log.
37+
- Optional: [MEM-P06-C-F2](agent-review-findings.md#mem-p06-c-f2--optional-one-sentence-in-the-decisions-note-one-untested-piece-of-wiring) (a, b).
38+
- Conflict resolutions, integration effects, 5c8528a0 and the decisions note: accepted. 41be07b2 matches the tree passed at MEM-P06-B3-R2 for every path of this plan.
2339

2440
## MEM-P06-B3-R2
2541

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)