CMS: analysis deposit form enrichments

[tiborsimko]

Comments from Wei:

Basic information

• Analysis Number
• Abstract/Conclusion (text box)

AOD process

• Primary Datasets
• Monte Carlo Datasets
• Selection Triggers
  • Each trigger has a short automated description on algorithm.
• Event selection
  • Event filter (drop down menu).
    • HCAL noise cleaning filter
      • Include a reference
    • Ecal spike removal
      • Include a reference
• MC signal&background selection
  • Signal (text box) (note: drop down can be hard to be comprehensive (e.g. D sample can include B->D and prompt D)
    • pt_hat bins and number of events in each bin(text box)
    • Generator and tune (drop down or text box)
    • pT (text box)
    • Rapidity or pseudorapidity (text box)
    • Decay channel (text box)
    • Decay engine (text box or drop down)
    • Any other information (text box)
  • Background (text box)
    • Which generator and which tune (drop down or text box)
    • Collision species (drop down) (for now include pp, PbPb, pPb).
    • Collision energy (text box)
    • pt_hat bins and number of events in each bin (text box)
    • Any other information (text box)

Physics Information

• Final State Particles
  • Cuts
  • Vetos
  • Tracking (drop down) (i.e. Heavy-ion tracking and pp tracking with references)
    • Special cuts on the tracks (text box).
  • Signal reconstruction and extraction (text box)
    • able to add plots or tables anywhere needed in the text.
  • Acceptance & Efficiency corrections (text box)
    • able to add plots or tables anywhere needed in the text
  • Background estimation & subtraction (text box)
    • able to add plots and tables anywhere needed in the text
  • Details of all systematic errors (text box)
    • able to add plots and tables anywhere needed in the text
  • Physics results (text box)
    • able to add plots and tables anywhere needed in the text
  • Appendix (text box)
    • able to add plots and tables anywhere needed in the text
  • Conclusions (text box)

Post-AOD Processing

• OS
• Analysis Software
• User Code
• Input Data Files
• Output Data
• How to Reproduce
  • Can one just push a single button?

Documentations

• CADI ID
  • Right now we need a AN to open a cadi.
• Comment
• Keyword
• URL

Internal Discussions

Presentations

Publications

• PAS
• Refereed journal

Additional features

• Need to accept latex format
• Need to save on time so people can continue working on it later.

[suenjedt]

Notes from face to face meeting:

• recall and reuse results from ND workshop: detector final state vs. physics final state. That influences the expected search behaviour. See also Gabriele's comment CMS Analysis preservation demo input form feedback #132
• need to gather the drop down fields. Need to differentiate heavy-ion physics in the form. E.g. Tracking information is already specific to Heavy ion
• add example text for suggested text boxes or suggestive questions that are shown in the box
• try to make more free text "drop down" controlled text
• need to have "threads" or tabs for different study areas or sections, this reflects the need to connect the input/output from specific software [challenge on how to include and expose that]

[suenjedt]

Most of this is done! Superseeded by #155
Remember: Need to accept latex format. @Kjili to double check completion of it (in other issues)